When Your Heart Stirs for Another
Navigating the Uncharted Waters of Married Attraction

It starts subtly. A glance lingers. A shared laugh surprises. You catch yourself thinking of someone besides your spouse, and shame follows. Though devoted, you feel drawn to another. This discomfort is nearly universal. The heart can love deeply yet still notice other allure. Such attraction doesn’t signal doom for your marriage. It can spur self-discovery and relational growth. The essential question is not feeling desire but how you respond.

The “Why”: The Psychology of Attraction Beyond the Promises

Understanding this desire’s roots is the first step to handling it wisely. Modern psychology views these sensations as signals about your inner life and your relationship—less betrayal than reflection.

Esther Perel, a renowned psychotherapist, offers a transformative perspective.  She contends that attraction to another person is often motivated by a lost aspect of oneself rather than by the relationship.  “Sometimes, when we seek the gaze of another, it isn’t our partner we are turning away from, but the person we have become,” she writes.  This attraction can be a hunger for “otherness”—a yearning to reconnect with a version of oneself who is active, curious, or independent, attributes that may have faded in the cosy, predictable routine of married life.

This is consistent with Perel’s description of the basic paradox of modern love: we need both stability and excitement, often from the same person.  In long-term relationships, she finds that “desire resists confinement,” and the issue is to reconcile “the domestic and the erotic”.  The attraction to someone new can indicate a need for that erotic aliveness—a longing for mystery and separateness that is sometimes drowned out by the togetherness of marriage.

From a biological and evolutionary perspective, a desire for variety is a natural human trait. The instinct for novelty is strong. Yet humans can commit, plan, and act ethically. The tension between old desire and modern fidelity helps define your character.

Echoes in History and Literature: You’re Not the First

History and literature are replete with stories of married couples drawn to one another, reminding us that this is a timeless human drama.

In the 16th century, King Henry VIII’s “notoriously wandering eye” fell on Anne Boleyn, a lady-in-waiting for his wife, Catherine of Aragon.  His extreme obsession drove him to break with the Roman Catholic Church, rewrite English history, and, ultimately, to Anne’s sad death.  This historical story demonstrates how unbridled desire, when combined with authority, can unleash terrible consequences far beyond the individual.

Earlier, King David saw Bathsheba, Uriah’s wife, and was overtaken by desire. To have her, he arranged her husband’s death. This story warns of desire divorced from duty and its cascading effects.

The Saravana Bhavan restaurant chain has over 80 locations worldwide. Thousands of dedicated customers and followers love their delicious, authentic South Indian food. On July 9, 2019, Saravana Bhavan founder P Rajagopal was sentenced to life in jail for murdering his employee’s son-in-law, the spouse of a young woman he wanted to marry.

P Rajagopal was a brilliant entrepreneur who went on a killing spree, a savvy businessman who developed a terrible passion for other men’s wives. He pursued his employee’s daughter, turning her life into hell. The woman whose husband was brutally murdered by his henchmen took down Rajagopal.

Literature reflects these internal struggles.  In Gustave Flaubert’s Madame Bovary, the protagonist, Emma, is caught in a boring marriage and longs for passionate romance.  Flaubert captures the constant push-and-pull within a restless heart: “Her will, like the veil strung to her bonnet, flutters in every breeze; always there is the desire urging, always the convention restraining”.  Emma’s tragedy is not in her emotions, but in her decisions—seeking to satisfy her need through external excursions rather than confronting the void within.

The Wisdom of Ancient Texts: Desire in Perspective

The ancient Indian scriptures offer significant and complementary insights into the nature of desire and a framework for understanding and managing these sentiments.

The Bhagavad Gita doesn’t condemn desire but explains its dynamics. “While contemplating the objects of the senses, a person develops attachment for them, and from such attachment lust develops, and from lust anger arises”. This is a mindfulness lesson: trouble begins not with emotion, but with unregulated mental focus—the fantasising that fuels attachment.

The Gita’s solution is not suppression, but rather mastery and transcendence.  It recommends building inner stability, comparing the wise person to an ocean unaffected by the rivers (desires) that flow into it.  The idea is to acknowledge the flow of attraction while avoiding being swept away by it.

The Kama Sutra, often misunderstood, is a guide to a balanced, ethical, and happy life. It treats desire as a natural aspect (Kama), best balanced with responsibility (Dharma) and prosperity (Artha). On temptation: “When we suppress our impulses, they do not evaporate; they remain beneath the surface and continue to exert their influence. Prohibition arouses desire and provides ways to satisfy it.” Rigid denial can make desires stronger and more elusive.

With these frameworks in mind, you might ask: How can you apply this knowledge to your own situation?

Moving Forward: What Should You Do?

When attraction arises, you stand at a crossroads. One path leads to secrecy, fantasy, and potential betrayal. The other encourages integrity, self-reflection, and deepening connection. Here is a guide to the latter.

• Breathe: Don’t panic or react. Your initial reaction is not your final decision.  Allow yourself to recognise the attraction without judgement.  It is knowledge, not an accusation against your marriage.
• Look Inward, Not Outward: Ask the hard questions, Perel advises. What does this attraction mean? Is it novelty, appreciation, stimulation, or a lost self you seek? What parts of yourself do you want to revive?
• Create Conscious Distance: If you interact with this person, set clear and immediate boundaries. Reduce alone time, keep all exchanges public and professional. This is respect, not rudeness, toward your spouse.
• Reinvest in Your Marriage: Often, outside attraction signals unmet needs in your relationship. Rather than seeking fulfilment elsewhere, return that energy to your spouse. Plan a date, deepen conversation, or try something new together.
• Communicate with Care (Optional: Depending on the nature of your relationship, you may decide to disclose your struggles with your partner. This is a high-risk, high-reward action that should be taken with considerable caution.  Frame it as a confession of your need to feel more connected, alive, or near to them, rather than an admission of attraction to another.  The emphasis must be on “us,” not “them.”

If you’re still struggling, you might consider seeking professional support.

How a Therapist Can Be Your Guide

It can be overwhelming to face this alone. A therapist offers a neutral, confidential setting to explore your feelings without collateral damage.

Individual Therapy: A therapist can help you explore these introspective questions.  Are these feelings the result of unresolved personal history, unmet self-esteem needs, or a midlife reevaluation?  They can help you comprehend the “why” behind the attraction and create emotional self-regulation skills by utilising lessons from the Gita on how to manage the “chain reaction” of desire.

Couples therapy: If this attraction reveals relationship flaws, a therapist can help with tough discussions. They help you address unmet needs, rekindle intimacy, and rebuild connection safely.

Reflecting on all these perspectives, what can we take away?

The Alchemy of Temptation

The sudden attraction to someone outside of your marriage is not a reflection of your history; it is a test of your current character and a question about your future.  It asks what you value.  Who do you wish to be?

While difficult, this experience may be just what keeps your marriage from becoming complacent.  It can shake you out of your complacency, prompting you to consider who you are as an individual and what you are co-creating as a partnership.  By facing the discomfort with honesty and courage—by reinvesting the energy of attraction in your own growth and your marriage bond—you conduct alchemy.  You transmute the base metal of temptation into the gold of increased self-awareness and conscious, chosen love.

Desire’s flutter will remain. Your strength is not in fighting it, but in choosing your anchor. Moored to your ideals, vows, and the deep, evolving love you’ve nurtured.

Click www.hopetrustindia.com for an online appointment with a therapist.